OK, so the fuel pump is toast. I got it out and tried it on the battery and it's froze up. The goo turns out to be some sort of rubber disk or something they used under the fuel pump to keep it quiet I'm guessing. But overall, The whole fuel pump assembly was a nasty mess, So I'm gonna get all the guts out of my parts car fuel tank and swap them. It should be running in the next day or 2 with any luck.