There are plenty of examples of unjust / error prone reporting in the world today. It boils down to individually trusting a particular publication for it best opinions. I agree with Larry iii that CR is great for TV's Refrig's, VCR's (dating myself
), or DVD's, but very lacking in automobile "understanding".
Remember "60 Minutes" on the Audi "unintended acceleration"? Did a job on Audi sales in the US and even when proven wrong, NEVER acknowledged it publicly! I seldom watch "60 Minutes" today for that very resaon - can't trust any of their reporting any more.
Harry