Hi Mandi-

Happy new year to you, too.

I had a very similar problem about a month ago. I cracked the rim on which the tire had gone flat. At the recommendation of some people here, I checked out www.car-parts.com and looked for the proper wheel for my car (remember, these cars have directional wheels, so you've gotta make sure you get the right one or the left one, whichever is bad). It brought up about 4 pages of used wheels from all around the country. The most expensive was nearly $300 and the cheapest was $55. If you're not concerned with how it looks (a couple scratches in the paint, worn-down center cap, etc.), just get the cheapest one they list. The page should list phone numbers, so just call the place with the wheel you want, ask them if they can do any better on the price (it can never hurt) and work out shipping. I got my wheel for $55 + $15 s/h COD.. it arrived in three days.

hope this helped!

-adam